Bill: Draft Contracts Act

[xXTheoryXx]

CONGRESS OF THE
COMMONWEALTH OF REDMONT
​

---

A BILL TO

Establish a Stronger, Fairer, and More Comprehensive Framework for Contract Law in the Commonwealth of Redmont

​

---

The people of the Commonwealth of Redmont, through their elected Representatives in the Congress and the force of law ordained to that Congress by the people through the constitution, do hereby enact the following provisions into law:
​

PART I - PRELIMINARIES

1. Short Title and Enactment

(1) This Act may be cited as the 'Contracts Act'.

(2) This Act shall be enacted immediately upon its signage.

(3) This Act has been authored by Speaker of the House xXTheoryXx.

(4) This Act has been co-sponsored by TrueDarkLander.

(5) This Act repeals the following legislation:

(a) Contracts Act

(6) This Act coordinates with the following legislation:

(a) Property Lien Act - which governs security interests, collateral, and lien enforcement arising out of or attached to contractual obligations.

(b) Legal Entity Act - which governs the capacity, authority, and liability of Incorporated Entities entering into contracts.

2. Reasons and Intent

(1) Contracts are the backbone of Redmont's economy. Every shop deal, construction agreement, employment arrangement, and business partnership runs on them.

(2) The prior contract law framework was vague, limited in application, and provided little practical guidance to players, courts, or businesses operating in Redmont.

(3) The purpose of this Act is to make contract law clear, fair, and actually useful - so that players can do business confidently, courts can resolve disputes consistently, and no one gets away with shady dealings behind a wall of legal vagueness.

(4) If you make a deal in Redmont, this Act governs it.

3. Definitions

(1) For the purposes of this Act, the following definitions shall apply:

(a) Acceptance. Unconditional agreement to all terms of an offer.

(b) Anticipatory Breach. Declaring in advance - by words or conduct - that a party will not perform their contractual obligations.

(c) Assignment. The transfer of contractual rights from one party to a third party.

(d) Capacity. The legal ability to enter a binding contract.

(e) Consideration. Something of value exchanged between parties as part of a contract.

(f) Counteroffer. A response to an offer that modifies the terms, killing the original offer and creating a new one.

(g) Damages. Monetary compensation for loss caused by a breach of contract.

(h) Duress. Illegitimate pressure or threats that coerce a party into entering a contract against their genuine will.

(i) Force Majeure. Unforeseeable and unavoidable events entirely beyond a party's control that prevent performance of a contract.

(j) Frustration. An unforeseen event making performance of a contract impossible or radically different from what was originally agreed.

(k) Good Faith. Honest, fair conduct in the performance of contractual obligations.

(l) Incorporated Entity. A corporation, LLC, or other legal entity formed under the Legal Entity Act, with legal personality separate from its owners and agents.

(m) Injunction. A court order requiring a party to stop doing - or start doing - something.

(n) Invalidity. The state of being legally void or unenforceable.

(o) Liquidated Damages. A pre-agreed sum payable upon a specified breach.

(p) Low Playtime. Fewer than 6 hours of total server playtime at the time of contracting.

(q) Material Breach. A fundamental failure going to the heart of a contract, depriving the innocent party of substantially the entire benefit they were due to receive.

(r) Minor Breach. A partial or technical failure that does not undermine the core of the contract.

(s) Misrepresentation. A false statement of fact that induces another party to enter a contract.

(t) Mistake. A fundamental and shared false belief about a material fact at the time of contracting.

(u) Mutual Agreement. The consent of all parties to a contract.

(v) Novation. The substitution of a new party for an existing party to a contract, with the consent of all parties, extinguishing the original party's obligations.

(w) Offer. A definite proposal to enter into a contract on stated terms.

(x) Offeree. The party to whom an offer is made.

(y) Offeror. The party making an offer.

(z) Performance. The fulfilment of contractual obligations.

(aa) Promise. A commitment made by one party without mutual consideration - not a contract and not enforceable under this Act.

(bb) Privity. The relationship that exists between parties to a contract, which generally limits who can enforce or be bound by it.

(cc) Remedies. Legal measures available to address a breach of contract.

(dd) Rescission. Cancellation of a contract, restoring parties to their original positions.

(ee) Security Agreement. A written agreement creating a lien over collateral to secure a contractual obligation, governed by the Property Lien Act.

(ff) Severability. The principle that invalid clauses can be removed from a contract without voiding the remainder.

(gg) Sole Proprietorship. An in-game business without an associated Incorporated Entity, where the owner bears all liability personally.

(hh) Specific Performance. A court order compelling a party to actually perform their contractual obligations.

(ii) Standard Form Contract. A pre-written contract offered by one party on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, with no meaningful opportunity for the other party to negotiate the terms.

(jj) Third Party. A person who is not a party to a contract but may be affected by it.

(kk) Undue Influence. Improper pressure that exploits a position of power or trust to induce a party to enter a contract against their genuine interests.

(ll) Waiver. Voluntarily giving up a right under a contract.

PART II - CONTRACT FORMATION

4. Elements of a Valid Contract

(1) A contract is a legally binding agreement between two or more parties that creates an obligation to do or not do a particular thing.

(2) A valid and enforceable contract requires all five of the following elements: Offer, Acceptance, Consideration, Intention to Create Legal Relations, and Capacity.

(3) If any one of these elements is absent, no binding contract exists.

5. Offer

(1) An offer is a clear and definite proposal by the Offeror to the Offeree, setting out the terms on which they are willing to be bound.

(2) An offer must be communicated to the Offeree - a party cannot be held to an offer they never received.

(3) An offer may be made in writing, verbally in-game, or through conduct that would lead a reasonable person to believe an offer has been made.

(a) Written offers include forum posts, direct messages on Discord or the forums, in-game signs, and books.

(4) An offer lapses if:

(a) It is not accepted within a reasonable time, or within any deadline stated in the offer;

(b) It is rejected or countered by the Offeree; or

(c) The Offeror withdraws it before acceptance. A withdrawal is only valid if communicated to the Offeree before acceptance occurs.

6. Acceptance

(1) Acceptance is the unconditional and unambiguous agreement by the Offeree to all terms of the offer.

(2) Acceptance must mirror the offer exactly. If the Offeree proposes any change to the terms, this constitutes a Counteroffer - not acceptance - and the roles of Offeror and Offeree reverse.

(3) Silence does not constitute acceptance. A party cannot be bound to a contract solely because they did not respond.

(4) Acceptance may be communicated through writing, verbal confirmation in-game, or conduct clearly indicating agreement, such as beginning performance of the agreed task.

7. Consideration

(1) Consideration is the exchange of something of value between parties - each party must give something in return for the other's promise.

(2) Consideration may be:

(a) Tangible, including money, items, materials, land, or in-game currency; or

(b) Intangible, including services, labour, information, or a promise not to do something.

(3) Consideration does not have to be equal in value. A bad deal is still a deal, provided it was freely entered into. Courts will not void contracts simply because one party received a better outcome.

(4) Past consideration - something already done before the contract was formed - is not valid consideration.

(5) A Promise without consideration is not a contract and is not enforceable under this Act, though it may give rise to other obligations at law.

8. Intention to Create Legal Relations

(1) Both parties must intend for their agreement to be legally binding.

(2) Commercial and business agreements are presumed to be intended as legally binding.

(3) Casual, social, or clearly joke arrangements are presumed not to be legally binding unless there is strong evidence to the contrary.

(a) Example: "I'll give you a stack of diamonds if you beat me in a race" said in passing chat is not a contract. A written deal for the same stakes is.

9. Capacity

(1) To enter a valid contract, a party must have legal capacity - meaning they are capable of understanding and agreeing to the terms.

(2) A player with fewer than 6 hours of total server playtime at the time of entering the contract is presumed to lack capacity, and the contract is voidable at their option.

(a) This protects new players from being exploited before they understand how the server works.

(b) A new player may affirm a contract - making it binding - once they reach 6 hours of playtime.

(3) A party acting under duress, undue influence, or while clearly not of sound judgement may also lack capacity at the court's discretion.

(4) Incorporated Entities have full capacity to enter contracts, subject to the powers and restrictions in their formation instrument and the Legal Entity Act.

(5) A contract entered into on behalf of an Incorporated Entity is binding on that entity where:

(a) The individual signing had actual authority under the formation instrument or a valid resolution; or

(b) The individual had apparent authority - meaning the other contracting party reasonably believed they had authority and had no notice otherwise.

(i) See Legal Entity Act, Part III Section 8 (Agency) for the full agency framework.

(6) A sole proprietorship's contractual obligations are the personal obligations of its owner. There is no separate entity shield.

PART III - FORM AND TERMS

10. Form of Contracts

(1) Contracts may be written or verbal.

(2) Written contracts are strongly encouraged and receive greater evidentiary weight in any dispute.

(3) A written contract is required for enforceability in the following cases:

(a) Agreements involving transfers of land or property valued over $5,000;

(b) Employment agreements lasting longer than 7 days; or

(c) Any agreement where a party specifically requests a written record.

(4) A written contract includes any agreement recorded in:

(a) A forum post or reply;

(b) A direct message on Discord or the forums;

(c) In-game signs or books; or

(d) Any other persistent text medium accessible to both parties.

(5) Verbal agreements may be corroborated by witnesses, screenshots of related chat, or circumstantial evidence of performance.

11. Standard Form Contracts

(1) A Standard Form Contract is binding where the party accepting it had a reasonable opportunity to read and understand the terms before agreeing.

(2) For a Standard Form Contract to be enforceable, the party presenting it must:

(a) Make the terms accessible before the other party commits - for example, by posting them on a public forum thread, on an in-game sign at the point of transaction, or in a direct message sent prior to the deal; and

(b) Not bury material terms - any term that significantly limits rights, imposes unusual obligations, or transfers substantial risk must be presented clearly and not hidden within a wall of unrelated text.

(3) A term in a Standard Form Contract is unenforceable if:

(a) The accepting party had no reasonable opportunity to read it before agreeing; or

(b) It is so unusual or onerous that it would not be expected in a contract of that type, and it was not specifically drawn to the accepting party's attention.

(4) The unfair terms provisions of Section 13 apply to Standard Form Contracts with full force.

12. Express Terms

(1) Express terms are those explicitly stated by the parties - the terms actually said or written down.

(2) All express terms form part of the contract.

13. Implied Terms

(1) Some terms are implied into contracts by law, custom, or the obvious intentions of the parties, even if not written down.

(2) A court may imply a term where:

(a) It is necessary to give the contract business sense;

(b) It is so obvious that both parties would have agreed to it without hesitation; or

(c) It is required by this Act or other applicable legislation.

(3) Implied terms may not override express terms.

14. Unfair Terms

(1) A term is unfair if it creates a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations to the detriment of one party, and that party had no real ability to negotiate it out.

(2) A court may strike out an unfair term under Section 26 (Severability), leaving the remainder of the contract intact.

(3) A term cannot exclude liability for fraud, deliberate misconduct, or a party's own criminal conduct.

PART IV - VITIATING FACTORS

15. Misrepresentation

(1) Misrepresentation occurs when a party makes a false statement of fact - not opinion - that induces the other party to enter the contract.

(2) Types of misrepresentation are as follows:

(a) Fraudulent Misrepresentation. A false statement made knowingly, recklessly, or without belief in its truth. Courts may void the contract and award additional damages.

(b) Negligent Misrepresentation. A false statement made carelessly, without reasonable grounds for believing it was true.

(c) Innocent Misrepresentation. A false statement made honestly and with reasonable belief it was true.

(3) The remedy for misrepresentation is Rescission and, where appropriate, damages.

(4) A party cannot escape liability for misrepresentation by claiming ignorance where they had the means to verify the truth.

16. Duress

(1) A contract is voidable at the innocent party's option where that party was induced to enter the contract by duress.

(2) Duress includes:

(a) Physical threats or threats of harm directed at the party or persons close to them;

(b) Threats to destroy or damage property; or

(c) Economic duress - illegitimate threats or pressure targeting a party's economic interests, where the party had no reasonable alternative but to agree.

(3) The mere fact that one party drove a hard bargain or had stronger negotiating power does not constitute duress. The pressure must be illegitimate.

(4) A party who affirms the contract after the duress has ended - by continuing to perform or expressly accepting its terms - loses the right to rescind on the basis of duress.

17. Undue Influence

(1) A contract is voidable at the innocent party's option where that party entered the contract as a result of undue influence.

(2) Undue influence arises where one party exploits a position of power, trust, or dependence over the other to procure their agreement.

(3) Undue influence may be actual - directly proven - or presumed where the relationship between the parties is such that influence is inherently likely, including but not limited to:

(a) Employer and employee, where the employee is contracting in a personal capacity;

(b) A dominant business partner and a junior partner; or

(c) Any relationship where one party has demonstrated significant authority or control over the other.

(4) Where undue influence is presumed, the burden shifts to the party in the position of power to demonstrate the other party entered the contract freely and with independent judgement - for example, by showing the other party received independent advice.

18. Mistake

(1) A contract may be void or voidable where it was entered into under a fundamental mistake of fact.

(2) A Common Mistake exists where both parties share the same false assumption about a material fact that is fundamental to the contract - and that fact did not exist or was radically different from what both believed.

(a) Example: Both parties contract for the sale of a specific plot of land, neither knowing it has already been claimed by a third party before the agreement was made.

(b) A Common Mistake that renders the subject matter of the contract non-existent at the time of contracting makes the contract void.

(c) A Common Mistake that makes performance radically different from what was contemplated may make the contract voidable at the court's discretion.

(3) A Unilateral Mistake exists where only one party is mistaken about a material fact, and the other party knew of, or ought reasonably to have known of, that mistake.

(a) A contract entered into under Unilateral Mistake where the other party exploited or caused the mistake is voidable at the innocent party's option.

(b) A genuine mistake about the value or quality of what is being contracted for - where both parties simply disagreed on worth - is not a Mistake in law and does not vitiate the contract.

(4) Mistake as to identity. Where a party contracts believing they are dealing with a specific identified person and that belief is false, and identity was material to their decision to contract, the contract is voidable.

(5) A party seeking relief on the ground of mistake must act promptly upon discovering the mistake. Unreasonable delay may result in the court declining relief.

19. Illegality

(1) A contract is void and unenforceable where its object, purpose, or performance requires a party to commit an act that is unlawful under the laws of Redmont or the rules of the server.

(2) No court shall enforce, award damages for, or grant any remedy in connection with an illegal contract.

(3) Examples of illegal contracts include but are not limited to:

(a) A contract to pay another player to grief, steal from, or harass a third party;

(b) A contract to launder money or disguise the origin of unlawfully obtained funds;

(c) A contract to provide false testimony or evidence in legal proceedings; or

(d) Any contract that requires a party to violate server rules in the course of performance.

(4) Where only part of a contract is illegal and that part is severable, the legal portions of the contract remain enforceable under Section 26 (Severability). However, where the illegal purpose is central to the entire agreement, the whole contract is void.

(5) A party who has transferred money or property under an illegal contract generally cannot recover it. However, a court may allow recovery where:

(a) The parties are not equally at fault - for example, where one party was deceived into the illegal arrangement; or

(b) The illegal purpose had not yet been carried out at the time recovery is sought.

PART V - BREACH OF CONTRACT

20. What Constitutes a Breach

(1) A breach of contract occurs when a party fails, without lawful excuse, to perform any obligation required of them under the contract.

(2) Breach may take the following forms:

(a) Actual Breach. The party has simply failed to do what they promised by the time performance was due.

(b) Anticipatory Breach. The party has made it clear - by words or conduct - that they will not perform their obligations when the time comes. The innocent party need not wait; they may treat the contract as terminated immediately and seek remedies without delay.

21. Material and Minor Breach

(1) A Material Breach is a fundamental failure that goes to the heart of the contract and deprives the innocent party of substantially the entire benefit they were supposed to receive.

(2) A Minor Breach is a partial or technical failure that does not undermine the core of the contract.

(3) Only a Material Breach entitles the innocent party to terminate the contract. A Minor Breach entitles the innocent party to damages only.

PART VI - REMEDIES

22. Damages

(1) Damages are monetary compensation paid by the breaching party to put the innocent party in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed.

(2) Expectation Damages compensate for the benefit the innocent party expected to receive.

(3) Reliance Damages compensate for losses incurred in reasonable reliance on the contract, such as money spent preparing to perform.

(4) Damages must be foreseeable. A party is not liable for bizarre or unforeseeable losses even if technically caused by their breach.

(5) The innocent party has a duty to mitigate - they must take reasonable steps to reduce their own losses and may not deliberately allow damages to accumulate.

(6) Liquidated Damages may be agreed in the contract as a pre-set amount payable upon breach, provided the amount is a genuine pre-estimate of likely loss and not a wildly punitive sum designed to punish rather than compensate.

23. Specific Performance

(1) A court may order Specific Performance, compelling the breaching party to actually perform what they promised.

(2) This remedy is appropriate where damages would be inadequate - for example, where a unique item, piece of land, or one-of-a-kind service was promised.

24. Rescission

(1) Where misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, operative mistake, or a sufficiently serious breach is established, a court may rescind the contract entirely, restoring both parties to their original positions as nearly as possible.

25. Injunction

(1) A court may order a party to stop doing something that breaches the contract, or that would cause irreparable harm pending the resolution of a dispute.

26. Lien Enforcement

(1) Where a contract includes a Security Agreement - meaning the parties agreed that specific property secures performance of the obligation - enforcement of that security interest is governed by the Property Lien Act, not this Act.

(2) A Lienholder may pursue lien enforcement and a breach of contract claim simultaneously, but may not recover twice for the same loss.

(3) The existence of a Security Agreement does not limit the innocent party's right to pursue damages under Section 22 for any loss not recovered through lien enforcement.

PART VII - PRIVITY, ASSIGNMENT, AND NOVATION

27. Privity of Contract

(1) As a general rule, only parties to a contract may enforce it or be bound by it. A Third Party who is not a party to the contract has no right to sue on it and cannot be sued under it.

(2) This general rule is subject to the following exceptions:

(a) Third Party Beneficiaries. Where a contract expressly confers a benefit on an identified Third Party and the parties clearly intended that Third Party to be able to enforce that benefit, the Third Party may bring a claim to enforce it.

(b) Assignment. Where contractual rights have been validly assigned to a Third Party under Section 28, that Third Party may enforce those rights.

(c) Novation. Where a new party has been substituted under Section 29, the new party steps into the original party's position with all associated rights and obligations.

(d) Any other exception established by law.

(3) A Third Party's right to enforce a benefit under Subsection 2(a) cannot be extinguished or varied without that Third Party's consent once they have relied upon it or accepted it.

28. Assignment

(1) A party may assign their contractual rights - but not their obligations - to a Third Party without the other contracting party's consent, unless:

(a) The contract expressly prohibits assignment; or

(b) The nature of the contract is so personal that the identity of the party holding the rights is material - for example, a contract for a personalised service.

(2) To be valid, an assignment must be:

(a) In writing; and

(b) Communicated to the other contracting party. The assignment takes effect from the date of that communication.

(3) The assignee takes the assigned rights subject to any defences or set-offs the other contracting party could have raised against the original party.

(4) The original party remains liable for their contractual obligations after assignment unless those obligations are novated under Section 29.

29. Novation

(1) A party's contractual obligations may only be transferred to a Third Party by Novation, which requires the consent of all parties to the original contract.

(2) A valid Novation must be:

(a) In writing; and

(b) Signed or acknowledged by all parties - the departing party, the incoming party, and the remaining contracting party.

(3) Upon Novation, the departing party is fully released from their obligations, and the incoming party assumes them as if they had been an original party.

(4) Novation is required when an Incorporated Entity's contracts are to be transferred to a successor entity as part of a merger, consolidation, or business sale, unless the Legal Entity Act otherwise provides for automatic succession.

PART VIII - GOOD FAITH, TERMINATION, AND FORCE MAJEURE

30. Good Faith and Fair Dealing

(1) Every contract covered by this Act carries an implied obligation of Good Faith and Fair Dealing.

(2) Parties must act honestly and must not deliberately undermine each other's ability to enjoy the benefits of the contract.

(3) Good faith does not require a party to sacrifice their own legitimate interests. It prohibits deliberately dishonest, manipulative, or obstructive behaviour in the performance of the contract.

(4) A party who acts in bad faith may face additional damages at the court's discretion.

31. Termination of Contract

(1) A contract may be terminated in the following ways:

(a) Mutual Agreement. All parties agree to end the contract.

(b) Performance. The contract has been fully performed by all parties and nothing remains to be done.

(c) Material Breach. The innocent party elects to terminate following a material breach by the other party, as described in Section 21.

(d) Frustration. An unforeseen event beyond any party's control has made performance impossible or radically different from what was contemplated, and neither party is at fault.

(e) Rescission. The contract is cancelled due to misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, mistake, or another vitiating factor, as described in Section 24.

(f) Expiry. The contract contains a term specifying an end date or condition, and that date or condition has been reached.

32. Force Majeure

(1) A Force Majeure event is an unforeseeable and unavoidable circumstance entirely beyond a party's control that prevents them from performing their obligations.

(2) Examples on DemocracyCraft may include unexpected server events, game-breaking bugs, or administrative actions directly affecting a party's ability to perform.

(3) The following are not Force Majeure events:

(a) Going broke due to bad business decisions;

(b) Losing items due to personal negligence;

(c) Forgetting about the contract; or

(d) Being banned for rule violations.

(4) The affected party must:

(a) Notify the other party as soon as reasonably possible; and

(b) Take all reasonable steps to minimise the impact and resume performance.

(5) If a Force Majeure event persists for an unreasonable period, either party may terminate the contract without liability.

PART IX - CONTRACTS WITH INCORPORATED ENTITIES

33. Contracting with Incorporated Entities

(1) A contract with an Incorporated Entity is enforceable against that entity as a separate legal person, with liability strictly distinct from its shareholders, members, and agents - unless personal liability has been expressly assumed under the Legal Entity Act.

(2) Where an Incorporated Entity is wound up, dissolved, or placed in receivership during the life of a contract:

(a) Contractual claims against the entity shall be treated as creditor claims in the winding up process;

(b) The innocent party should notify the entity, its directors, and the Department of Commerce of their claim within 14 days of any public announcement of dissolution, or their claim may be waived under the Legal Entity Act; and

(c) Where the entity is in receivership, the receiver inherits the powers of directors and may elect to affirm or disclaim the contract.

(3) A contract that purports to dissolve, wind up, or fundamentally alter the structure of an Incorporated Entity without following the procedures in the Legal Entity Act is void to that extent.

(4) Employment contracts and service contracts where an Incorporated Entity is a party are subject to this Act. The fiduciary duty obligations of directors and officers under the Legal Entity Act are separate from and additional to their contractual obligations.

PART X - MISCELLANEOUS

34. Prohibition of Binding Arbitration

(1) No contract may require parties to submit disputes exclusively to private, binding arbitration in place of the court system.

(2) Any such clause is void and unenforceable.

(3) This does not prohibit:

(a) Voluntary, non-binding mediation where either party may still proceed to court afterwards; or

(b) Settlement agreements freely reached after a dispute has arisen.

(4) Under Section 35 (Severability), the rest of the contract remains valid even if an arbitration clause is struck out.

35. Severability

(1) Every provision of a contract is severable from the rest, unless the contract expressly states otherwise.

(2) If one clause is found to be invalid, unlawful, or unenforceable, that clause is removed. The remainder of the contract stands.

(3) A court may modify a severed clause to the minimum extent necessary to make it enforceable, rather than removing it entirely, if that better reflects the parties' original intentions.

36. Limitation Period

(1) A party wishing to bring a claim for breach of contract must file their case within 30 days of becoming aware of the breach, or within 60 days of the breach occurring - whichever is earlier.

(2) A court may extend this period where exceptional circumstances prevented timely filing, at its discretion.

(3) Claims filed outside this window may be dismissed.